Skip to content
Blogs Best-practices

Off-the-shelf vs custom software: what really decides it

Off-the-shelf vs custom software: what really decides your choice

Off-the-shelf vs custom software: this is what really decides your choice, and it is not the number of features on the supplier's website. There are hundreds of packages and every salesperson tells you that their system is a perfect fit for your business. That cannot all be true, because your business works slightly differently from your neighbour's.

You know the conversation. You sit down with a supplier, he shows you a demo and everything looks logical. Create a quote, start a project, send an invoice. Three clicks and done. Only after six months do you notice that your purchasing is still in Excel, that the workshop has its own planning board and that service runs through email and a shared folder. The new system works fine, but only for the part that was in the demo.

That is not bad software. It is an off-the-shelf package that does what it was built for. The process is already built in and you have to work the way the package intends. If your work fits within that mould, you quickly have a good system at an affordable price. If a large part of your work falls outside it, you start working around it. And that working around costs hours every week, even though it never appears on an invoice.

The reflex then is to jump the other way: let's just have it built ourselves. Then it fits exactly. But a custom project for an entire business quickly costs a few hundred thousand euros, it takes a long time and every change afterwards costs money again. Many business owners only see these two options. There is a third, and it changes how you make the choice.

Three types of system, not two

Once you understand that there are three types of system, choosing becomes a lot easier. The first is ready-made software, also known as off-the-shelf. Log in and get started, with a fixed process such as quote to project to invoice. Fast and affordable, but you follow the supplier's mould. For a small agency with one clear process that is often exactly right, and in that case I would not look any further either.

The second is custom software. Software built for you from the first line of code. It fits exactly, but it is expensive and slow. At a few hundred thousand euros for a whole business and extra costs for every change, it is mainly for businesses with a way of working that truly exists nowhere else.

The third sits in between: a platform you set up with building blocks. Think of it as Lego. There is no fixed process built in, so you set it up the way you work. That takes more work up front, because you first need to be clear yourself about how you work. After that you can expand step by step as your business grows, without starting again.

So the choice between these three does not depend on which package is the nicest. It depends on how your work is structured. The best system is not the package with the most features, but the system that fits how you work and how you want to grow. To get that clear, I use three questions.

Three questions that make the choice

1. Does your work follow one fixed cycle?

If almost everything in your business runs from quote to invoice, an off-the-shelf package will probably fit well. But look honestly at what happens outside that cycle. Purchasing, stock, production, service, maintenance. The more that happens outside that one line, the less a standard package fits. An agency of eight people that only sells hours sits almost entirely within one cycle. A project business that buys materials, produces and then provides service for years sits within it for perhaps half of its work.

A simple test: take your last ten jobs and go through them in your head. For how many of them did someone have to keep track of something in a separate list, an email or a spreadsheet? If it is two, a package is fine. If it is seven, you already know enough.

2. How many departments have their own system?

Count them. If sales has a CRM, planning its own tool, the workshop an Excel file and service a shared mailbox, you have four islands. The problem there is rarely that a system is missing. The problem is that they do not talk to each other. Adding yet another separate system makes it worse. You need something that connects those departments, so that information is entered once and is correct everywhere.

You notice those islands mainly at the moments things go wrong. A customer calls about a fault and service does not know which parts were supplied at the time. Or planning schedules an engineer while the materials have not yet arrived, because purchasing works in a different file. Those are not people's mistakes, they are gaps between systems.

3. What happens when you add a new process?

Suppose that a year from now you start a service department or begin renting alongside selling. Can your system handle that, or will you have to look for something new again? This is the question that is skipped most often, because everyone chooses based on how the business looks today. Choose based on where you want to be in one year, two years or five years.

Look first at what you already have

A new system does not mean everything has to go. Your accounting software or your ERP often does its job perfectly well and does not need replacing. What is needed: the new system must be able to talk to it. That saves money, it saves hassle with your accountant and your team does not have to relearn everything at once. So do not just ask a supplier what their package can do, but also how it connects with what is already in place.

And to be fair: not every business needs the same thing. A small agency with one process can often manage perfectly well with an off-the-shelf system, and it would be a waste to spend months on setup work. A project business with several departments and a lot of work outside the standard gets nothing out of that. There, the up-front work of a platform with building blocks pays off, or in the odd case custom software.

The question of off-the-shelf or custom software is actually framed too narrowly. Anyone who only chooses between those two pays either with workarounds in a package that does not fit, or with a few hundred thousand euros for software that costs money again with every change. Anyone who answers the three questions first knows within an afternoon where to look. That is why at Lead Innovation we always start with how you work now and where you want to be in five years, and only then with the system.

Want to know more about monday.com?

The Lead Innovation team at work